|
RECOMMENDED
BOOKS, ARTICLES
AND WEB
SITES
There has not been much written on the image of journalists
in movies, television, radio or fiction. The IJPC hopes to
rectify this in the future.
In the meantime, the Image of the Journalist
in Popular Culture recommends the following books, articles
and Web sites.
Please e-mail us at saltzman@usc.edu
if you have any additional recommendations for this resources
page.
Updated: 4-2008
POPULAR CULTURE
Analyzing
the Images of the Journalist in Popular Culture: A Unique
Method of Studying the Public's Perception of Its Journalists
and the News Media: “A long-neglected,
fertile field for research virtually untapped by journalism
and mass communication scholars”by Joe Saltzman,
Professor of Journalism, Director of the Image of the Journalist
in Popular Culture (IJPC), A Project of the Norman Lear Center,
Annenberg School for Communication, University of Southern
California. By analyzing the images of the journalist in popular
culture over the centuries, the researcher can offer a new
perspective on the history of journalism as well as the delicate
relationship between the public and its news media. The anger
and lack of confidence most of the public has in the news
media today is partly based on real-life examples they have
seen and heard, but much of the image of the journalist is
based on images burned into the public memory from movies,
TV and fiction. These images of the journalist have an enormous
influence on how the public perceives and judges the news
media and they have a profound effect on public opinion and
consequently, the public’s support of the effectiveness
and freedom of the news media. Many of these images come from
age-old sources, long forgotten yet still relevant in the
21st century. Variations of this paper were delivered at the
“Media History and History in the Media” conference
at the University of Wales, March 31-April 1, 2005 at Gregynog,
Wales, and at the Association for Education for Journalism
and Mass Communications (AEJMC) in San Antonio, Texas, August
12, 2005.
FILMS
Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Journalists in Movies
Richard R. Ness's From Headline Hunter to Superman:
A Journalism Filmography is by far the best book yet
written on the journalist in film. Published in October 1997,
it is a superb guide to more than 2,100 feature films dealing
with journalism, the definitive reference book on the image
of the journalist in film. It is available from Scarecrow
Press (www.scarecrowpress.com).
Also "From
a Voice in the Night to a Face in the Crowd, the Rise and
Fall of the Radio Film" by Richard R. Ness,
Western Illinois University. Paper delivered at the AEJMC
Conference in San Francisco, August 2006. It is no mere coincidence
that Hollywood conversion to sound coincided with the development
of radio as a major force for both information and entertainment.That
radio provided not only a source of competition but also a
potential form of promotion for the motion picture industry
led to an often uneasy alliance between the two media, and,
as with the newspaper profession, Hollywood demonstrated a
love-hate relationship in its depiction of radio and its practitioners.
IJPC
Needs Your Help.
Click here for a list of films we still are attempting to
locate as part of our research for the Image of the Journalist
in Popular Culture project. The films are listed first alphabetically
and then by year of release. If anyone knows of sources
for any of these titles (including video and film sources,
as well the availability of copies in archives), please contact
Dr. Richard Ness, Associate Director of the IJPC, at RR-Ness@wiu.edu.
Any assistance is greatly appreciated. Revised 8-2006.
Howard Good, coordinator of the journalism program at the
State University of New York at New Paltz, is one of the few
scholars in America who writes about the subject and has written
three books dealing with the journalist in film: Outcasts:
The Image of Journalists in Contemporary Film (1989);
Girl Reporter: Gender, Journalism and Movies (1998),
and The Drunken Journalist: The Biography of a Film
Stereotype. All are recommended, filled with information
available nowhere else. They are available from Scarecrow
Press. (www.scarecrowpress.com).
Good's latest book, written with Michael J. Dillon, professor
of communications at Duquesne University, is Media Ethics
Goes to the Movies (Praeger Publishers, CT, 2002).
The best book ever written on the reporter in film is currently
out of print. It was written by a Canadian newspaperman named
Alex Barris, Stop the Presses! The Newspaperman in American
Films (A.S. Barnes and Co., South Brunswick and New
York, 1976.). It's worth seeking out. Specialty book stores
may have a used copy and it occasionally surfaces in online
auctions.
Also worth ferreting out is Loren Ghiglione's The American
Journalist: Paradox of the Press (Library of Congress,
Washington, DC, 1990), written for a Library of Congress exhibit
on the image of the journalist. Dr. Ghiglione is dean of the
Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern.
Fact or Fiction:
Hollywood Looks at the News. An essay by Loren Ghiglione,
Dean of the Medill School of Journalism, Northwestern University,
and Joe Saltzman, Director of the IJPC and Associate Dean,
USC Annenberg School for Communication -- © Loren Ghiglione/Joe
Saltzman 2002
The American Journalist: Fictions
Versus Fact. An essay by Loren Ghiglione, Dean of
the Medill School of Journalism, Northwestern University.
©American Antiquarian Society, 1991.
Frank Capra and the Image
of the Journalist in American Film. "The
first book of the IJPC project, Frank Capra and the Image
of the Journalist in American Film, sets a precedent of excellence
in scholarship, writing, and readability, serving academics,
students, and film aficionados alike ...Academics will find
it a valuable resource, especially if teaching a course that
examines the image of the journalist, a Capra course, or even
a film genres course." Journalism & Mass Communication
Quarterly, Spring 2003.
Frank Capra and the Image
of the Journalist in American Film USC Literary Luncheon
Speech, March 27, 2002, Doheny Memorial Library © Joe
Saltzman
Matthew C. Ehrlich's
book, Journalism
in the Movies (University
of Illinois Press), is an excellent summary suitable for
class use. For more information, see an Article-Review
on the book: "Journalism through the camera's eye: Book
looks at how Hollywood shapes our views of the press."
Ehrlich, associate professor at the University of
Illinois Department of Journalism, has studied and written
about journalism movies for 13 years and has been an invaluable
resource to the IJPC.
Facts,
Truth and Bad Journalists in the Movies by Matthew
C. Ehrlich in Journalism, Vol. 7, No. 4, 501-519 (2006) ©
Sage Publications 2006. Scholars have called for cultural
analyses of the press that are more attuned to journalists’
self-image as disciples of facts and truth while also critically
examining the contradictions within that self-image. Popular
representations of journalism such as motion pictures are
one fruitful site of inquiry. This article studies American
movies’ depictions of ‘bad journalists’,
characters who in many ways contradict the image of upstanding
professionalism that the press tries to promote. Although
real-life journalists over the years have often objected to
such portrayals, ‘bad journalist’ characters still
have helped shore up the press’s preferred self-image,
either by seeing through lies and pretense to the truth or
by paying the price for not telling the truth.
Hollywood
and the Journalistic Truthtelling by Matthew
C. Ehrlich, Associate Professor of Journalism at the University
of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. This article was published
in the Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy,
19(2), 2005: 519-539. Ehrlich's book Journalism in the
Movies (2004) was published by the University of Illinois
Press. The article looks at what has been called the paramount
principle of journalism -- truthtelling -- as it is depicted
in a movie about a notorious real-life case of journalistic
deception: Shattered Glass, the story of Stephen
Glass who in 1998 was fired for fabricating more than two
dozen stories for the New Republic magazine.
Other excellent writings on the subject by Ehrlich include
"Journalism in Movies," Critical Studies
in Mass Communication, Vol. 14, 1997, pp. 267-281, a critical
overview of the genre; "Thinking Critically about
Journalism Through Popular Culture," Journalism
& Mass Communication Educator, Vol. 50, No. 4, 1996,
pp.35-51, a documentation of a class on the subject taught
by Ehrlich, and "The Romance of Hildy Johnson: The
Journalist as Mythic Hero in American Cinema," Studies
in Symbolic Interaction, Vol. 12, 1991, pp. 89-104.
An extensive, but unpublished, survey of journalists in film
was compiled by Maxwell Taylor Courson, The Newspaper
Movies: An Analysis of the Rise and Decline of the News Gatherer
as a Hero in American Motion Pictures, 1900-1974: a Dissertation
submitted to the Graduate Division of the University of Hawaii
in partial Fulfillment of the requirements for the degree
of Doctor of Philosophy in American Studies, August, 1976.
It's available from UMI
Dissertation Express, Order No. 7702805.
With
Pad and Pencil: Old Stereotypes in a New Form? A comparison
of the Image of the Journalist in the Movies from 1930-1949
and 1990-2004, thesis submitted by Wibke
Ehlers, 2006, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for
the Degree of Master of Arts in Mass Communication in the
University of Canterbury. The thesis aims to provide an insight
into the stereotypical imagery of journalists on the screen
and its changes in popular culture, namely in film.
Movie
Journalists: Hello Hollywood by
Sarah Niblock, Brunel University, London in the British Journalism
Review, Vol.18, No. 1 69-75 (2007). Journalists on film
have for decades offered fantasy, fun and escapism to millions,
but most of the movies have emerged from Hollywood. And that
could be changing now that three new high-profile British-led
or inspired productions are in the pipeline.
Stephen Vaughn and Bruce Evensen, "Democracy's Guardians:
Hollywood's Portrait of Reporters, 1930-1945," Journalism
Quarterly, Vol. 68, No. 4, 1991, pp. 829-838, looks at
PCA files to see how the newspaper industry tried to influence
depictions of the press in the movies.
Thomas H. Zynda, "The
Hollywood Version: Movie Portrayals of the Press," Journalism
History,
Vol. 6, No. 1, 1979, pp. 16-25, 32, is a scholarly overview
of how movies have depicted journalism up to 1979.
Brooks Robards' "Newshounds and Sob Sisters: The Journalist
Goes to Hollywood," in Beyond the Stars: Stock Characters
in American Popular Film (by Paul Loukides and Linda
K. Fuller, Bowling Green State University Popular Press, Bowling
Green, Ohio, 1990, pp. 131-145) is a well-done, if brief,
survey.
Jane Baum's "The Female Journalist in American
Film, 1930-1949," 1983. University of Rochester.
Pauline Kael's "Raising Kane," 1971, in The
Citizen Kane Book (Limelight Edition, 1984. Pp. 3
to 84.) offers Kael's observations on the journalist in film
in her essay on what many consider the greatest American film
ever made.
Bonnie S. Brennen's From
Headline Shooter to Picture Snatcher, the construction of
photojournalists in American Film, 1928-1939.
Brennen was chair of the department of journalism at Temple
University's School of Communications and Theater. Her research
project focuses on the construction of photojournalists in
20 American films, in which photojournalists and cameramen
appear as central characters, produced during the late 1920s
and 1930s.
Malice
in Wonderland: Hedda Hopper and Louella Parsons in Hollywood
by Bonnie Brennen, Temple University. Louella Parsons and
Hedda Hopper were powerful, unconventional women who ruled
Hollywood at a time when women were still considered second-class
citizens. Thriving amid glamour and wealth, these gossip columnists,
with a readership of about 75 million, could make or break
the career of an aspiring actor, writer, or director.
Norma Green's The Front Page on Film as Case Study
of American Journalism Mythology in Motion, is an
excellent Ph.D. dissertation on the subject, Mass Media at
Michigan State University, Fall, 1993. The University
Microfilm Order No. is 9418000.
Norma Green's "Press Dress: The Beige Brigade of Movie
Journalists Outdoors," in Beyond the Stars,
edited by Paul Loukides and Linda K. Fuller, pp. 65-76 (Bowling
Green, Ohio: Bowling Green University Popular Press, 1990).
Larry Langman's The Media in the Movies: A Catalog
of American Journalism Films, 1900-1996 (McFarland
& Company, 1998) is eclipsed by Ness' book, but it offers
another comprehensive view of the image of the journalist
in American films.
Thomas C. Leonard's News for All: America's Coming-Of-Age
with the Press (Oxford University Press, 1995) includes
a chapter about journalism movies.
James Harvey's Romantic Comedy in Hollywood,
from Lubitsch to Sturges (Da Capo Press, 1998 paper edition)
includes material on screwball newspaper films.
Robert Brent Toplin's History of Hollywood:
The Use and Abuse of the American Past (University
of Illinois Press, 1996) is a collection of essays including
one on All the President's Men.
John Gregory Dunne's Monster: Living Off the Big
Screen (Vintage Books paper edition, 1998) gives the
backstage story on how he and his wife, Joan Didion, adapted
Up Close and Personal from the Jessica Savitch story.
Crime, Romance and Sex:
Washington Women Journalists in Recent Popular Fiction
by Stacy L. Spaulding, assistant professor of journalism,
Columbia Union College and Maurine H. Beasley, Professor of
Journalism, Philip Merrill College of Journalism. This study
of 13 novels portraying Washington women journalists finds
their portrayals have improved since 1990 when one authority
concluded that most novels showed women as "unfulfilled
unfortunates." The fictional women in this study, featured
most prominently in detective stories, are eager to expose
male corruption to further their careers but make little effort
to change underlying social causes. These women are searching
for relationships, but their careers still take precedence
Mediated Dialogue: HBO'S
Live From Baghdad was presented at the
WSCA Conference in Albuquerque, New Mexico in February, 2004.
The writers, Arthur W. Herbig IV and Kelly Parker, are master’s
students at Saint Louis University. The paper takes a look
at the film that focuses on CNN’s media revolution and
the sudden impact of 24-hour news reporting from the Persian
Gulf War. The movie examines the roles media play in how the
public understands and interprets broadcast news. This paper
examines media roles in encouraging and mediating dialogue
since media criticism often neglects dialogue as one of its
components. In doing so, the authors examine Live from
Baghdad to determine what it says about public dialogue.
.
Print (and Video) to Screen: Journalism
in Motion Pictures of the 1990s
by Paul Steinle, Department of Communication, Southern
Oregon University. Presented at the Popular Culture/American
Culture Conference in New Orleans, April, 2000. Updated, October
22, 2002. © Paul Steinle
Sweat Not Melodrama:
Reading the Structure of Feeling in All the President's
Men, by Bonnie Brennen, associate professor,
Missouri School of Journalism. This essay suggests that the
most famous chronicle of this political scandal codifies an
ideology of journalism that has framed an understanding of
the role of the press in the United States and Western Europe
since the 1970s. Copyright 2003 by SAGE Publications.
Matt Slovick of the Washington Post has two good
articles on Journalists
in the Movies and All
The President's Men.
Democracy's Guardians: Hollywood's Portrait of Reporters,
1930-1945 by Stephen Vaughn and Bruce Evensen, Journalism
Quarterly 68:829-38.
In Journalism and Mass Communication, UC Berkeley under
Images
of Journalism and the Media in the Movies, there is
a good listing of movies and references.
Glenn Garelik's "Stop the
Presses: Movies Blast Media. Viewers Cheer"
is about movie portrayals of journalists that reflect changes
in the news media industry. New York Times, Jan. 31, 1993.
Debra Gersh's "Stereotyping Journalists:
Whether in Movies from the 1930s or the 1980s, newspeople
are usually portrayed as rude, divorced, hard-drinking, cigarette-smoking
misfits." Editor & Publisher, Oct. 5, 1991.
Clyde Haberman's "A Version of My Job, Made
for TV" (Television Portrayals of Journalists).
The New York Times, Oct. 7, 2000.
Christopher Hanson's "Where Have All the Heroes
Gone?" (Journalists are no longer portrayed
as Heroes). Columbia Journalism Review, March-April, 1996.
Bill Mahon's "Portrayal of Journalists in Movies."
Editor & Publisher, Oct. 1, 1994.
Brooks Robards, "Newshounds and Sob Sisters:
The Journalist Goes to Hollywood," in Beyond
the Stars: Stock Characters in American Popular Film
edited by Paul Loukides and Linda K. Fuller, pp. 131-145.
(Bowling Green, Ohio: Bowling Green University Popular Press).
Chip Rowe, "Hacks on Film" discusses
portrayals of reporters by television and film including filmography
of best films about journalism. Washington Journalism Review,
November, 1992.
Carl Sessions, "Film Dour" is
about journalism portrayed in motion pictures. American Journalism
Review, January, 2000, pg 56.
Gerald Stone and John Lee's "Portrayal of Journalists
on Prime Time Television." Journalism Quarterly,
Winter 1990, pgs. 829-838.
Bernard Weintraub's "Bad Guys, Good Guys: Journalists
in the Movies," an analysis of how journalists
are portrayed in motion pictures. Living Arts Pages, The New
York Times, Oct. 13, 1997.
Media Alliance board member and media worker MiHi Ahn lists
her Top
10 Best Movies About the Media in a special MediaFile.
Poynter.org's Dr.
Ink offers a list of media movies compiled by David
Shedden, the Poynter librarian.
Paul
Schindler has a passion for the subject and his energetic
Web site
is filled with good humor and insights. .
The Detroit
Free Press offers a nicely designed Web site on journalism
movies. It is an attractive introduction to the subject.
Reporters usually show up in horror films. Joe Winters explores
the subject in "The Monsters
Meet the Press."
Malcolm Johnson takes an entertaining look at female journalists
in movies in "When the News
is Bad for Women" appearing in The Age, Melbourne,
Australia, June 10, 2002
A student publication of the Lemke Journalism Department
at the University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, Observations,
offers an article by Casey Pittman, In the Movies, Journalists
Are No Longer Heroes -- Just Like Everywhere Else. A Large
Majority of the American Public Feels The Press No Longer
Deals Fairly With Issues.
Mark Bowden, “When the Front Page Meets
the Big Screen,” The Atlantic Monthly,
Vol. 293, No. 2, March 2004, p. 146 (5 pgs, 3016 words): “Hollywood
is not a reliable moral arbiter of anything, so it’s
not surprising that when it holds a mirror up to journalism,
Shattered Glass, is the result." Bowden, who
is a national correspondent for The Atlantic Monthly,
writes: “Given how poorly journalists usually fare
in opinion polls (ranking somewhere near tax collectors),
and how plainly their excesses figure in history and in daily
life, it is remarkable what a staunch ally the profession
seems to have in Hollywood. The reporter may be even more
of a celluloid staple than the private detective.” The
article is mostly a personal analysis of Absence of Malice
and All the President’s Men in relationship
to Shattered Glass. It includes a summary of films
about journalism and what they have meant to the author.
Giorgio Gosetti, Jean-Michel Frodon, Alain Bergala's "Print
the Legend: Cinema and Journalism," Paris, Cahiers
du cinema. Locarno. Festival Internazationale del film del
Locarno, 2004. Buffalo State College Library has a copy.
Court-TV's
15 Most Memorable Movie Journalists lists its
favorite compelling cinematic newshounds.
Jeremy Martin's "No Cheering for the Press Box:
The Stereotypes of Sports Journalists in Film,"
California State University, Fresno, Department of Mass Communication
and Journalism, Thesis-Dissertation, 2004.
Caroline Graham Austin's"Pressing Issues: Fictional
Women Journalists in American Film," Thesis-Dissertation,
1996. University of Notre Dame Library.
Carol Maria McCarthy's "Idiots, Scoundrels and
Screwballs: The Image of Journalists in Popular American Film,"
Thesis-Dissertation, 1991, University of Maryland, College
Park.
Bill Bilodeau's "Portrayals of Journalists in
Academy Award-Nominated Films, 1927-1993: A Qualitative Analysis,"
Thesis-Dissertation, 1994. University of South Florida.
Barbara A. Brucker's "The Journalist as Popular
Hero or 'Up in the Sky, It's a Bird, It's a Plane, It's Clark
Kent," Thesis-Dissertation, 1980. . Bowling
Green State University.
Charles E. McKenzie's "The Reel World: A Study
of Cinematic Journalists and What They Might Teach Audiences
About Journalism," Thesis-Dissertation. 2001.
University of South Florida Library.
Cinemateca Portuguesa's "Jornalismo e cinema,"
Lisboa Expresso: Cinemateca Portuguesa, 1993. Yale
University Library. Indiana University Library. Boston Public
Library
Kyle Ross McDaniel's "Reviewing
the Image of the Photojournalist in Film: How Ethical Dilemmas
Shape Stereotypes of the On-Screen Press Photographer in Motion
Pictures from 1954 to 2006," a thesis presented
to the Faculty of the Graduate School at the University of
Missouri-Columbia, in partial fulfillment of the requirements
for the degree Master of Arts, August 2007.
Favorite
Journalism Films Listing. Newscoach list of movies. No Train,
No Pain Web Site.
THE
RETURN OF THE SOB SISTER IN 'SUPERMAN RETURNS': LOIS LANE
AND THE FIGHT FOR TRUTH AND JUSTICE by Mary-Lou
Galician, a faculty member at Arizona State University's Walter
Cronkite School of Journalism & Mass Communication.
I
Wish I Were Lois Lane by
Simone Gianarelli, a Trobe University Media studies student
who wrote this article about female journalists in movies.
TELEVISION
Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Journalists in Television
A comprehensive book covering all the prime
time network television programs including ones featuring
journalists is Tim Brooks and Earle Marsh The Complete
Directory to Prime Time Network TV Shows, 1946-Present,
Seventh Edition, completely revised and updated, Ballantine
Books, New York, 1999, 1392 pages.
Douglass K. Daniel's Lou Grant: The Making of TV's
Top Newspaper Drama (Syracuse
University Press, 1996) explores the history of the medium's
most-respected journalism series and how it depicted the profession.
It contains an overview of journalism dramas up to the debut
of Lou Grant as well as a synopsis of each of the 114
episodes that aired from 1977-1982.
Robert S. Alley and Irby B. Brown's Love Is All Around:
The Making of the Mary Tyler Moore Show (a Delta Book
published by Dell Publishing, Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing
Group Inc., New York, 1989, 235 pages paperback). The same
authors also wrote Murphy Brown: Anatomy of a Sitcom
(Dell, 1990, 304 pages). Each book discusses
the making of the television programs "from original
idea to script, casting and pilot." Plot summaries included.
Aralynn Ann Abare McMane's "Hello, Handsome,
Get Me Rewrite: Toward an Understanding of the Portrayal of
the Female Journalist in Film and on Television." 1991.
Diana Meehan's Ladies of the Evening: Women Characters
of Prime-Time Television, The Scarecrow Press, 1983, 192 pages.
NOVELS AND SHORT STORIES Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Journalists in Novels and Short Stories
Howard Good's Acquainted with the Night:
The Image of Journalists in American Fiction, 1890-1930,
is the definitive book on the image of the journalist in fiction
(The Scarecrow Press, Inc. Metuchen, N.J. & London, 1986,
139 pages).. Also, Good's "The Image of War Correspondents
in Anglo-American Fiction," Association for Education
in Journalism and Mass Communication, 1986, Journalism Monograph,
pp. 1-25.
Loren Ghiglione's The American Journalist:
Paradox of the Press (Library of Congress, Washington,
DC, 1990), written for a Library of Congress exhibit on the
image of the journalist, is one of the best resources for
novels about journalism and journalists.
Steve Weinberg, formerly a professor of journalism at the
University of Missouri, started collecting novels of and by
journalists in 1983. He presented his collection
to the University of Missouri-Columbia Libraries in 1989
and periodically supplements the collections with new additions.
There are more than 830 volumes in the collection. All titles
are cataloged and available through MERLIN, the University's
online catalog. His articles on the subject include "My
Great White Whale, or the Great Newspaper Novel," for
New York Times (Aug. 27, 1989, sec. 7, p. 1) and The
Reporter in the Novel by Steve Weinberg (Columbia
Journalism Review, v 36, pp. 17-18, November-December, 1997.
Since I started collecting novels with journalists as protagonists,
I have acquired some 1,300 of them, of some 2,300 out there....In
fact, I worry a lot about the unrealistic picture a nonjournalist
must take away from these novels: according to most of them,
we lack an ethical center, sleep regularly with sources, and
solve so many crimes, especially murders, that it is a wonder
the police have anything to do."
James Geraty Harrison, American Newspaper Journalism
as Described in American Novels of the 19th century, Ph.D.
dissertation, University of North Carolina, 1945.
Also, James G. Harrison's "Nineteenth-Century American
Novels on American Journalism I," Journalism Quarterly,
September 1945, Volume 22, Number 3, pp. 215-224, and "Nineteenth-Century
American Novels on American Journalism II," Journalism
Quarterly, December 1945, Volume 22, Number 4, pp. 335-345.
Margaret Klein, "Journalists in Some Nineteenth
Century Fiction," Thesis-Dissertation. 1929.
OCLC: 56156160. Columbia University Libraries, New York.
Thomas Elliott Berry's, The Newspaper in the American
Novel, 1900-1969, The Scarecrow Press, Inc., Metuchen,
N.J. 1970, 170 pages.
William McKeen's Heroes and Villains: A Study of Journalists
in American Novels Published Between 1915 and 1975,
Indiana University, 1977 (submitted to the faculty of
the Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements
for the Masters of Arts Degree in the School of Journalism,
Indiana University, August, 1977. p. 1-121). Also, "Tough
Guys with Typewriters," Studies in Popular
Culture, Spring, 1980.
Donna Born's "The Image of the Woman Journalist in
American Popular Fiction, 1890 to the Present," a
Paper Presented to the Committee of the Association for Education
in Journalism, Annual Convention, Michigan State University,
East Lansing, August, 1981, pp. 1-45. Also, "The Woman
Journalist of the 1920s and 1930s in Fiction and in Autobiography,"
presented to the Qualitative Studies Division, Association
for Education in Journalism Annual Convention, Ohio, July
1982, pp. 1-24. Born was an assistant professor in the Department
of Journalism at Central Michigan University.
Jean
Marie Lutes' "Front-Page Girls: Women Journalists
in American Culture and Fiction, 1880-1930,"
Cornell University Press, 2007. This is the first
study of the newspaperwoman in American literary culture at
the turn of the 20th century. It examines the relationship
of real-life reporters such as Nellie Bly and Ida B. Wells
with fictional characters such as Henrietta Stackpole, the
lady correspondent in Henry James' "Portrait of a Lady."
It chronicles the exploits of a a neglected group of American
women writers and uncovers an alternative reporter-novelist
tradition that runs counter to the more familiar story of
gritty realism generated in male-dominated newsrooms. It also
explores how women's journalism shaped the path from news
to novels for women writers.
Also, Lutes' Sob Sisterhood Revisited,"
(American Literary History - Volume 15, Number 3, Fall, 2003,
pp. 504-532, Oxford University Press), and "Into
the Madhouse with Nellie Bly: Girl Stunt Reporting in Late
Nineteenth Century America" (American Quarterly,
Volume 54, Number 2, June 2002, pp. 217-253).
Bonnie Sue Brennen's Peasantry of the Press: A History
of American Newsworkers from Novels, 1919-1938,"
Thesis-Dissertation, 1993. University of Iowa Library.
H.H. McClure's "Inside Views of Fiction: III -- The
Newspaper Novel," Bookman, Volume XXXI, March-August
1910, pp. 60-61.
Jay Black's Ethics of the Fictional Journalist: How
Novelists Portray Decision-making in the News Business,"
1994. Emerson College Library.
John Luther Windrow's "Getting a Bad Press:
the Image of the Journalists in Fiction Written by Journalists
in the 1980's." Thesis-dissertation,
1996. OCLC: 63290954. University of Minnesota, Minneapolis
Library.
Heidi M. Langner-Burns' "The Image of Journalists
in American Film and Fiction from 1975 to 1987: An Application
of Leo Lowenthal's Model," School of Journalism,
Southern Illinois University at Carbondale, 1989.
Carri Gregorski, Denny Wilkins, John Hanchette, Paul J. Spaeth,
James Snyder, James Webb's "Ethical Journalism:
Traditional Newsgathering, Journalism in Film and an Examination
of 'All The President's Men.'" St. Bonaventure
University, 2003. Thesis-Dissertation-Book.
Fiction
or Truth by Steve Hallock, The Quill (Chicago,
Ill.) v. 85, pp. 31-34, May, 1997. Just as cops and lawyers
and coaches and politicians complain about how they are treated
in newspaper stories, journalists lament their treatment at
the hands of fiction authors. An inspection of six novels
of newspapers or newspaper characters yielded some nuggets
of reality, but these nuggets were hidden among the negative
stereotypes, cliches and myths. The most troubling aspect
of these books is the attitude toward journalism conveyed
by the authors. If fiction mirrors society, there is little
doubt the public distrusts the news media or that reporters
are viewed as an arrogant pack feeding on society's ills.
Hugh Lessig's News Noir Web
site is an entertaining look at the journalist in
fiction. As Lessig puts it: "Hardboiled tales and newspapers.
They've gone together from the beginning. The River City
Blade is a fictional paper, devoted to the spirit of the
hardboiled newspaperman. Its sister paper is called The Frisco
Foil, and I've based a few stories there -- when I feel
like writing about the West Coast. Whether it's the Foil or
the Blade, whether it was Kennedy of the Free Press or Kolchak
of Night Stalker fame, reporters always stick their notebooks
where they don't belong."
SCOOP!
JOURNALISTS IN FICTION Web site.
"Journalists appear in fiction in many guises and play
many roles. Sometimes they provide central characters, often
they intrude on the action, their attentions as unwelcome
as they often are in real life. Scoop! gathers together these
appearances under a variety of themes, some amusing, some
trivial, some giving an insight into how the Press works and
how it is seen to impact on our society."
PUBLIC
RELATIONS Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Public Relations Practitioners
Karen
S. Miller's Public Relations in Film and Fiction, 1930
to 1995, Journal of Public Relations Research 11
(1):3-28, 1999. Miller is an associate professor
of advertising and public relations in the College of Journalism
and Mass Communication at the University of Georgia.
Emily Kinsky, Texas Tech University, "The
Portrayal of Public Relations Practitioners in The West
Wing," a paper presented at the 2006 AEJMC
Convention in San Francisco. An investigation of the portrayal
of public relations practitioners was performed using content
analysis of the 22 episodes in the debut season of The
West Wing. The practitioners were coded based on demonstrated
traits and work performed or discussed. Significant differences
were found between male and female practitioners being included
or disciplined, appearing as major characters, dealing with
government officials and the media, discussing speech writing,
and appearing silly.
Kaye D. Trammell, University of Georgia and
Lisa K. Lundy, Louisiana State University, "Perception
of Public Relations: An Experiment Testing the Impact of Entertainment
Portrayals of the Profession on Students and Practitioners,"
a paper presented at the 2006 AEJMC Convention in
San Francisco. Researchers investigated the impact of entertainment
portrayals of the public relations profession. Findings indicate
that while all groups believe the portrayal of the profession
in the stimulus was inaccurate, participants allowed the entertainment
program to cloud their perception of public relations. Respondents
experienced third-person effects but the phenomenon dissipated
as one's connection to the profession decreased.
Youjin Choi, University of Florida, "Effects
of Entertainment Television Program Viewing on Student's Perceptions
of Public Relations Functions," a paper
presented at the 2006 AEJMC Convention in San Francisco. This
study conducted a survey with students in an introductory
public relations course to examine the effects of television
viewing of entertainment programs with public relations characters
on the perceptions about public relations functions. A factor
analysis classified students;' perceptions into five categories:
two-way communications, political communication, spokesperson
, writing, and informal media relations.
ART
AND PHOTOGRAPHY Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Journalists in Art and Photography
Images of the Combat Journalist –
Reality & Fantasy, a
power point presentation by Dr. David Natharius, Adjunct
Professor, Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication,
Arizona State University. Presented to the Western States
Communication Association Convention, Albuquerque, NM, Feb.
15, 2004, and to the National Communication Association (NCA)
Convention, Chicago, IL, Nov. 12, 2004.
Nora Paul, director, Institute for New Media
Studies, University of Minnesota, has a newspaper
art collection of postcards and memorabilia, an extraordinary
collection.
COMIC BOOKS Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Journalists in Comic Books
Everything
I Need To Know About Journalism I Learned From Superman
(And Other Comic Books) by Tom Henderson, managing
editor of the Polk County Itemizer-Observer in Dallas, Oregon,
and “Mild Mannered Reporter” columnist for the
paper. He is also President of the Society of Professional
Journalists Greater Oregon Professional Chapter.
"It's
a bird...it's a plane...it's a journalist?" A Framing
Analysis of the Representation of Journalists and the Press
in Comic Book Films. A Thesis Submitted to the
Faculty of the Graduate School of the University in Minnesota
by Katherine Ann (Beck) Foss in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the Degree of Master of Art. October 2004.
EXTRA!
The Comic Book Journalist Survives the Censors of 1955 by
Tom Brislin, Journalism History v. 21, pp. 123-130. Autumn,
1995. EXTRA! is a 1955 comic book that chose journalists as
its protagonists. Unlike other comics that used the journalist
to mask a secret superhero identity, such as Superman or Spider-man,
EXTRA! portrayed the journal sits themselves, albeit in glorified
form, as the heroes. EXTRA! built an impressive cast with
an image of journalists that fit nearly into professional
and gender stereotypes of the era. The male journalists were
young, rugged and handsome, unencumbered by family, social,
or community obligations. They were more likely to use their
fists or a gun than a pen or camera. Women were easily divisible
into "hard" and "soft" character types:
Women journalists were "hard," equal in mettle to
the males in the profession. The remainder of the sex was
"soft," either in or making trouble. Women always
played a part in getting the story; often they were the reward
for male journalists afterward.
MUSIC
Click
Here for Alphabetized List of Authors on Journalists in Music
Tabloid
Suite: Four Pictures of a Modern Newspaper
composed by Ferde Grofe in 1932 consists of Picture No.
1: Run of the News (3:31). Picture No. 2 – Sob Sister
(5:23). Picture No. 3 – Comic Strip (3:11). Picture
No. 4 – Going to Press (7:38). New CD just released.
"We Both Reached for the Gun"
from the musical, Chicago (1976
on the Broadway stage, 2003 in the movies) with lyrics by
Fred Ebb, Fred (Lyrics). John Kander (Music). Shows the manipulation
of the media by an attorney in dynamic musical form. Tabloid
Columnist Mary Sunshine. Attorney Billy & Reporters: "Oh
Yes, Oh Yes, Oh Yes They Both, Oh Yes, They Both Oh Yes, They
Both Reached For the Gun, The Gun, The Gun, The Gun Oh Yes,
They Both Reached For The Gun, For the Gun." Mary Sunshine:
"You poor dear! I can't believe what you've been through!
A convent girl! A runaway marriage! Oh, it's too, too terrible.
Now tell us, Roxie…." Reporters: "Why'd You
Shoot Him?"… What's your Statement?…"
Mary Sunshine dances with Billy: "Understandable. Understandable."
With Billy: "Yes, It’s Perfectly Understandable."
Mary Sunshine bounces in mid-air pulled by strings. Billy
and Mary: "Comprehensible. Comprehensible." Mary
Sunshine picks up Roxie and puts her back in Billy's lap.
"Not a Bit Reprehensible. It's So Defensible." Reporters:
"Oh Yes, Oh Yes, Oh Yes, They Both, Oh Yes, They Both
Reached For…" Billy: "Let me hear it."
Reporters: "The Gun, The Gun, The Gun, The Gun, Oh Yes,
They Both Reached For The Gun, For The Gun." Billy: "Now
you got it!" Mary Sunshine rips out an article on an
Underwood and hands it to a Copy Boy. The sequence ends with
a series of Chicago newspapers rolling off the presses with
the headlines: "They Both Reached for the Gun."
"Whatchulooinat"
by Whitney Houston in 2003 album, Just Whitney.
Concerns Tabloid Editor of the National Enquirer. Letter to
the editor disguised as an R-and-B song: "Messin' with
my reputation, ain't even got no education. God is the reason
my soul is free, and I don't need you looking at me."
"Dirt" from the 2002
Broadway musical, Sweet Smell of Success, sung
by Gossip Columnist J.J. Hunsecker (John Lithgow). Entire
musical involves newspaper and gossip columnists. Hunsecker
is based on Gossip Columnist Walter Winchell in this musical
adaptation of the 1965 movie.
.
"The Sky is Falling" from
the TV children's program, Happily Ever After:
Fairy Tales for Every Child: Henny Penny, a TV
children's program created in 1999, with music and lyrics
by Spencer Preffer and Steve Punkett. Reporter Henny Penny
sings "The Sky is Falling" (performed
by Patti Welch): "I've got the biggest story ever heard,
they will hang on every word, I'm going to be a famous bird.
Yes, I've got the biggest scoop I've ever had. The story's
bound to be my launching pad. The sky is falling, you'd better
watch your head, the sky is falling, the headline will be
read, and everybody will know before it falls, that I'm the
best reporter of them all. I'm sure the Pulitzer is mine,
I will sign the dotted line on a book deal so divine. Yes
Hollywood will demand the movie's rights and I'll be on the
stage on Oscar Night. The sky is falling, You'd better watch
your head, the sky is falling, the headline will be read.
And everybody will know before it falls, that I'm the best
reporter of them all.The sky is falling, you'd better watch
your head, the sky is falling, the headline will be read.
Woodward and Bernstein won't even get a call, cause I'm the
top reporter, the number one reporter, yes, I'm the best reporter
of them all.
"Dirty Laundry" sung
by Don Henley in 1982: Journalist's cry, ""Come
and whisper in my ear….We love dirty laundry.""
Refrain shouts: ""Kick 'em when they're up. Kick
'em when they're down. Kick 'em all around."
"Extra, Extra" from
the 1942 film, The Blazing Trail,
Editor Smiley Burnett of the Bradytown Bugle hawking his papers
and singing: "Extra. Extra here. Buy a paper. Extra.
Extra here. You can read all about it. All the latest gossip
on the beat. Tells you what you want to know and who’s
been doing what. Buy it for two cents a sheet. Extra, extra,
here you can read all about it. The bulldog edition’s
on the street. Plumb full of scandals, swindles and fights.
Buy it for two cents a sheet."
"Jimmy Olsen's Blues," from
the 1991 Spin Doctors album, "Pocket Full of Kryptonite."
Cub Reporter-Photographer Olsen is in love with Reporter Lois
Lane and laments he can't compete with Superman. "Well,
I don't think I can handle this A cloudy day in Metropolis
I think I'll talk to my analyst I got it so bad for this little
journalist. It drives me up the wall and through the roof
Lois and Clark in a telephone booth. I think I'm going out
of my brain I got it so bad for little miss Lois Lane. Lois
Lane please put me in your plan Yeah, Lois Lane you don't
need no Super Man. Come on downtown and stay with me tonight,
I got a pocket full of kryptonite.He's Leaping buildings in
a single bound I'm reading Shakespeare at my place downtown.
Come on downtown and make love to me, I'm Jimmy Olsen not
a titan, you see. He's faster than a bullet, stronger than
a train. He's Leaping buildings in a single bound I'm reading
Shakespeare at my place downtown. Come on downtown and make
love to me, I'm Jimmy Olsen not a titan, you see. He's faster
than a bullet, stronger than a train…"
Meet John Doe: The Musical,
lyrics by Eddie Sugarman and music by Andrew Gerle, premiere
in Washington D.C. Ford Theatre, 3-27-2007. Reporter Ann Mitchell
loses her job in the middle of the Depression so she prints
a phony letter from a “John Doe” who, protesting
the state of society, promises to jump off the Brooklyn Bridge
on Christmas Eve. Circulation goes through the roof and she
convinces her editor to hire an out-of-work ballplayer to
stand in for John Doe. The ambitious newspaper reporter ghost
writes the “John Doe” column. With his words and
his down-home charm, John Doe quickly becomes a national sensation.
When the paper’s powerful owner reveals true plans for
John Doe, both Ann and John must confront what they’ve
created and decide what they truly believe in.
"I'm Your Man" from
the musical, "Meet John Doe." Lyrics by Eddie Sugarman
and Music by Andrew Gerle. Reporter Ann Mitchell sings this
song to Editor Richard Connell trying to get her job back
on the paper: “You want fireworks? I’ll give ya
the Fourth of July! Lots of luck finding somebody better than
I. Simply smashing. Really, Chief, you’re quite astute.
Your plane’s crashing -- and you ditch your parachute.
You need someone with talent and passion and brains. You need
someone with newspaper ink in their veins. No coffee cup has
lipstick stains, but Brother, I’m your man.
I’ll write just what you say, anyway that you want.
And when it comes to arguing I’m a savant!
Use my column, Any topic, take your pick. I can slalom Back
and forth on rhetoric! You need someone who crosses her legs
and her T’s. I’m so quick that I’ve got
my own personal breeze.
I’ve got high heels and two of these, but Brother I’m
your man.
I don’t need this position! So go on and throw out a
gem. You have stiff competition. Dick! You can go to hell.
I’ll go and work for them! Anything you need done, I’m
the one for the job.
You want corny? I’ll type it right off of the cob. I
need money, You need me to make a stir. Rent my fingers, I’ll
throw in a Pulitzer!
Front Page headlines will keep Mom and me off the street.
Come tomorrow some editor’s in for a treat. Just say
the word, and that’s my beat! Brother, I’m your
man.
Watch out, New York. Here comes -- Ann!.
|